Leupold model comparisons
Original Leupold BX-1 McKenzie 8x42, 10x42, and 12x50 compared
These are the original BX-1 McKenzie configurations on Leupold’s U.S. discontinued binocular directory page 3: 8x42 part 173787, 10x42 part 173788, and 12x50 part 173790. They are not the separately numbered BX-1 McKenzie HD models. Leupold’s exact product pages mark all three as discontinued and no longer available for purchase. This comparison is for identifying an existing instrument and understanding its published design; it is not a substitute for a current model shortlist or a used-item inspection.
The three size choices at a glance
- 8x42, part 173787: 330 ft/1,000 yd field (6.1°), 17.7 mm eye relief, 5.3 mm exit pupil, 10 ft close focus, 56–74 mm IPD, 22.1 oz, and 5.8 in length.
- 10x42, part 173788: 305 ft/1,000 yd (5.8°), 13.7 mm eye relief, 4.2 mm exit pupil, 10 ft close focus, 56–74 mm IPD, 22 oz, and 5.8 in length.
- 12x50, part 173790: 242 ft/1,000 yd (4.6°), 13.7 mm eye relief, 3.6 mm exit pupil, 12 ft close focus, 58–74 mm IPD, 28.5 oz, and 6.7 in length.
These measurements come from the exact Leupold product pages, not a test bench. The linear fields are stated at 1,000 yards. The exit pupil is the listed geometric figure; it is not a measured brightness value. Leupold describes all three with a broad low-light claim, but no independent transmission or twilight test is available here to compare their actual images.
Which one makes sense for which viewing task?
The 8x42 is the scanning choice in this trio. Its wider 330-foot scene gives more room to locate a moving bird or wildlife, and lower power is generally easier to hold on target by hand. It also carries the longest listed eye relief and nearly matches the 10x42’s weight. If a viewer’s main constraint is glasses comfort, 17.7 mm is the most promising number among these three on paper—but eye-relief figures are only a screening aid; eye socket shape, eyecup position, and individual glasses determine actual full-field access.
The 10x42 trades some scene width for additional magnification without moving into the larger 50 mm size. It weighs only 0.1 ounce less than 8x42 according to the product pages, so the real selection question is not a large weight saving: it is whether the narrower 305-foot field and shorter 13.7 mm eye relief make sense for the intended view. That relief deserves a real glasses check. It is also less forgiving of hand movement than 8x, though the exact experience depends on the viewer and how the binocular is held.
The 12x50 is the detail-oriented option for distant subjects that are relatively steady. It has the highest power and largest objective but also the narrowest listed view, heaviest body, shortest listed eye relief, and farthest near-focus distance. Its 1/4-20 tripod port gives a documented route to supported viewing, but Leupold does not confirm a mounting adapter in the supplied kit. The 12x50 is not an automatic “brighter” option: its listed exit pupil is actually smaller than the 8x42’s, and none of those figures measures real-world contrast or transmission.
Features they share—and details they do not establish
The exact pages describe a fully multi-coated lens system, Leupold’s Advanced Optical System, rubber armor, central focus, twist-up eyecups, waterproof/fogproof construction, and a rotatable 1/4-20 tripod port. The manufacturer does not publish a numeric immersion depth, duration, or IP rating for these configurations. “Waterproof” should not be read as an underwater-use specification. The pages do not establish ED glass, prism type, phase-correcting coating, or a locking diopter. Fully multi-coated lenses are not proof of any of those separate properties.
All three pages link the same general two-page Binocular Owner’s Manual. It explains hinge spacing, focus and diopter setup, eyecup positioning, and lens care; it does not provide model-specific optical measurements. The 8x42 and 12x50 pages list a GO Afield strap, case, covers, and cloth; the 10x42 page lists a Pro Gear shoulder strap, case, covers, and cloth. That description cannot establish what is in a particular secondhand box. Check the individual instrument, glass, focus, hinge, eyecups, and accessories.
What to compare now
For a current 8x42 size reference, open the BX-4 Pro Guide HD Gen 2 8x42 review; for current 10x42 and 12x50 comparisons, see the BX-3 Alpine HD 10x42 and BX-3 Alpine HD 12x50 assessments. These are distinct models, not assumed replacements. When choosing a current pair, start from how far away the subjects are, whether broad scene width or reach matters more, whether eyeglasses require longer usable eye relief, and how much weight you will actually carry. These original McKenzie profiles remain reference-only because the manufacturer marks them discontinued.