Leupold model comparisons

Leupold BX-1 McKenzie HD 8x42, 10x42 and 50 mm sizes compared

The BX-1 McKenzie HD family is easier to compare by first choosing how much magnification and objective size you can use comfortably. The gray-finish U.S. family has 8x42, 10x42, 10x50 and 12x50 configurations, with a separately numbered 10x42 Mossy Oak Bottomland version. Leupold has marked each of these listings discontinued and no longer for sale, so this is a model-identification and comparison guide rather than a current shopping recommendation.

Start with field and steadiness

The gray 8x42 publishes the broadest field in the group at 320 feet per 1,000 yards. It is the sensible format to inspect when you mostly scan, follow moving subjects or want lower magnification to make hand movement less obvious. The 10x42 reduces the listed field to 304 feet and adds reach while staying at the lighter 22-ounce tier. The 10x50 keeps 10x, moves to a larger objective and gives a 263-foot field at 27 ounces. The 12x50 has the narrowest listed field at 241 feet and more magnification; its view is more demanding to hold steady.

Those specifications describe framing and instrument weight, not measured image quality. A larger objective by itself does not prove a brighter view, and an “HD” label is not evidence of ED glass. The official product pages describe an Abbe-Koenig prism and an Advanced Optical System; they do not provide independent test results in the material reviewed. Choose by the use you can sustain, not a marketing adjective.

Field and fit snapshot

Exact partFormatField / 1,000 ydListed weightFit note
1811728x42, gray320 ft22 oz17 mm eye relief; page and catalog length differ
18117310x42, gray304 ft22 oz12 mm eye relief; check with glasses
18285210x42, Mossy Oak Bottomland304 ft22 oz12 mm listed eye relief; page and catalog angle figures differ
18117410x50, gray263 ft27 oz17 mm eye relief; larger 50 mm body
18117512x50, gray241 ft27 ozEye relief is unresolved: page 17 mm, 2026 catalog 12 mm

The figures are manufacturer listings. A field-width number is useful when tracking birds or panning across open ground, while weight matters if the binocular is carried all day. Nominal eye relief and interpupillary distance are screening clues, not a guarantee of facial comfort. Adjust the hinge and test the full view with the glasses you actually use. In particular, do not make a glasses-fit decision on the 12x50’s conflicting eye-relief data without trying the instrument.

When the 50 mm models make sense

Both 50 mm configurations weigh 27 ounces and measure 6.5 inches in the exact pages. The 10x50 is the less specialized of the pair: it keeps 10x, has a wider listed field than the 12x50 and lists 17 mm of eye relief. The 12x50 trades field for more enlargement, but the image is more sensitive to hand movement. If your normal viewing is from a vehicle, a pack or another stable rest, 12x may suit; if you will hold the instrument while walking and scanning, begin with the 8x42 or 10x42.

Leupold describes all these models as waterproof and fogproof, but the product material does not give an IP rating or immersion depth. The exact product descriptions list a strap, case, lens covers and cloth; Leupold’s catalog package list names the GO Afield harness, lens covers and cloth but omits the case. Confirm what is present with any used unit instead of assuming a historical box is complete. The pages do not confirm a tripod adapter in the package.

Find the exact finish and part

The Mossy Oak Bottomland 10x42 is part 182852, not a generic camo description for gray part 181173. The pattern is the visible distinction; both are 10x42 and list the same linear field and weight. The camo page gives 5.7 degrees while the 2024 catalog gives 5.8 degrees, so the angular value is not used to rank the two. The exact page lists 10 feet of close focus; the gray 181173 page lists 9.8 feet. These small differences should be retained as published rather than turned into a story about an optical improvement.

For an existing binocular, read the part number on the item, inspect the hinge, focus wheel and replaceable eyecups, and check the condition of the optics. The common Rev N manual provides general setup and care steps, including hinge, focus and cleaning guidance. It is not a model-specific repair guide. If you are instead shopping for a current binocular, compare active models on their own pages; the BX-2 Timberline HD 10x42, BX-4 Pro Guide HD Gen 2 sizes and BX-5 Santiam HD line are distinct designs, not simply renamed McKenzie sizes.

Sources: Leupold’s exact pages for 181172, 181173, 182852, 181174 and 181175; Leupold 2026 Consumer Guide; Leupold 2024 International Catalog; Leupold Binocular Owner’s Manual, Rev N.

Make the view work with your face and your outing.

Build my shortlist →